Skip to main content Scroll Top
logo main

The Cost of Editing Yourself

The Cost of Editing Yourself

The cost of editing yourself

I had a recent conversation that I haven’t been able to get out of my mind. It started with someone offering to introduce me to a potential guest for my podcast, Go First. This person has an incredible story, an impressive career, and the kind of name that would undoubtedly bring new attention to the show. 

From a podcast growth perspective, it was exactly the kind of opportunity you’re supposed to want. 

As we talked, something came up that made me hesitate. Because of this person’s position and the expectations that come with it, there were parts of his story he likely wouldn’t be able to share. Not because he didn’t want to be honest or because he had anything to hide, but because telling the whole story could come at a professional cost. 

I understood that. I could appreciate the position he was in and the responsibilities he had to consider. But I also knew that the parts of his story he might need to leave out were probably the very parts I would most want to hear. 

When I started Go First, I wanted to create a space for conversations about what it really takes to move through uncertainty, make difficult decisions, and build a meaningful life. I’m interested in what happens behind the accomplishments and the carefully written biographies. I want to know what people struggled with, what they got wrong, what they had to work through, and how those experiences changed them. 

Those are the stories that have always meant the most to me. 

And suddenly, I found myself confronting an uncomfortable question. What happens when the success you’ve worked so hard to build becomes the very thing that prevents you from telling the truth about how you got there? 

The Stories We Never Get to Hear 

The more I thought about this potential guest, the more I found myself feeling sad about the situation. Part of that sadness was for him, because I know what it feels like to carry experiences that aren’t easy to talk about. And I wondered what it must feel like to have a story that could mean so much to someone else, but to believe that sharing it could put everything you’ve built at risk. 

I’ve shared parts of my own life that were incredibly difficult to talk about. I’ve spoken openly about divorce, building a business, living with a scarcity mindset, anxiety, and the years of personal work it took to understand and move through some of those experiences. 

There was nothing particularly glamorous about any of it, and there were plenty of moments I wasn’t proud of. But some of the most meaningful connections I’ve made have happened because I was willing to talk about those things. 

I’ve had people approach me after speaking engagements or send me messages after hearing something I shared, simply to say that they needed to hear it. Sometimes they were going through something similar. Other times, their circumstances were completely different, but something about my experience gave them a new way to understand their own. 

I think about those conversations often because they remind me that we rarely know who needs to hear what we’ve been through. 

And that was the other part of my sadness. Somewhere, there is probably someone going through exactly what this potential guest experienced, convinced that they’re the only person who has ever felt that way. His story might have given them some perspective, a little confidence, or simply the reassurance that there is a way through it. 

When we keep those stories to ourselves, we may be protecting something important. But there is also something lost for the people who might have learned from them. 

When Success Starts Changing Your Story 

As I continued thinking about this conversation, my thoughts eventually turned to my own journey and career path. 

What if, somewhere along the way, I started doing the same thing? 

I don’t think most people make a conscious decision to become less honest about who they are. I think it happens gradually, through a series of small decisions that seem perfectly reasonable at the time. 

Someone suggests that a particular story might not be appropriate for an audience. Your marketing team recommends changing the ending of a personal experience so it lands a little better. Someone who cares about your reputation encourages you to be more careful about what you share. 

You start considering who might be in the room, what opportunities might be affected, or how a particular story could change someone’s perception of you. 

And because each individual decision seems so minor, you don’t necessarily notice what’s happening. 

But I wonder what happens after years of making those edits. How much of yourself can you leave out before the version everyone knows is no longer quite the person you are? 

I’ve had people tell me throughout my career that I’m too much. That maybe I should tone things down, be a little more careful, or reconsider how much of myself I put out into the world. 

I understand that those suggestions often come from people who genuinely want the best for me. They have their own perspectives, experiences, and comfort levels, and they’re offering advice based on what they believe will protect me. 

But I’ve spent enough time working on myself to recognize that making other people comfortable cannot be the thing that determines how I show up. 

The older I get, the more important it becomes to me that people feel seen. I want someone to hear a piece of my story and recognize something in their own, even when our experiences look nothing alike. 

And I can’t create that kind of connection if I’m constantly deciding which parts of myself are acceptable to share. 

There’s a Difference Between Privacy and Filtering 

I want to be careful here because I don’t believe that being authentic means telling everyone everything. 

There are parts of my life that I keep private because they belong to me, my children, or other people I love. Some experiences involve people who haven’t chosen to make their stories public, and I respect that. There are also things I’ve lived through that needed years of reflection and healing before I was ready to talk about them. 

I’ve always believed that we need to share from a healed wound rather than an open one. When we’re still in the middle of something painful, we may not have the perspective to understand what it means or how sharing it might affect ourselves and others. 

That work matters. So does having boundaries. 

But I’ve been thinking about the difference between choosing privacy and filtering yourself, because from the outside they can look almost identical. 

In both cases, there’s a story you aren’t telling. The difference is why you’ve decided to keep it to yourself. 

When I choose privacy, I’m making a decision about what belongs to me and what I’m comfortable sharing. I’m considering the people involved and whether I’ve done enough of my own work to speak about the experience in a way that’s useful. 

Filtering feels different. It’s when I start making those decisions based on what someone else might think of me. I’m protecting an image, an opportunity, or someone’s expectation of how a CEO, speaker, or business owner is supposed to behave. 

And the difficult part is that I’m the only person who can really know which one I’m doing. 

I have to be willing to ask myself what my silence is protecting. 

If it’s protecting someone I love, or a part of my life that deserves to remain private, I can feel good about that decision. But if I’m staying quiet because I’m afraid of losing someone’s approval, I need to pay attention. 

Because that’s where the editing begins. 

The People Who Need the Unpolished Version of You 

One of the things I’ve become more intentional about is creating spaces where people can have the kinds of conversations they don’t always feel comfortable having elsewhere. 

Whether I’m hosting a podcast, bringing people together for dinner, leading an executive retreat, or speaking to a room of leaders, I want people to feel like they can talk about the experiences that shaped them without having to make everything sound impressive. 

I’ve learned that the conversations people remember are often the ones where someone was willing to be a little more honest than the situation required. 

It’s rarely the polished story about everything going according to plan that stays with us. It’s hearing someone you admire acknowledge that they were scared, that they made a decision they regret, or that they spent years trying to figure something out. 

There’s something powerful about realizing that the people we look up to have experienced many of the same things we have. 

I feel fortunate that I’ve built a life and a career where I have the freedom to share my story in my own way. I don’t have to answer to an employer who might be uncomfortable with what I say, and I’m increasingly intentional about surrounding myself with people who understand why this matters to me. 

That doesn’t mean everyone will agree with how I show up. I know there will be rooms where parts of my story make people uncomfortable, and opportunities where being more reserved might make things easier. 

I’m learning to be okay with that. 

Because the more I think about it, the more I realize that I don’t want to spend my life becoming a version of myself that fits comfortably into every room. 

I want to be able to walk into a room with my whole story, including the parts that took me years to understand, and know that I haven’t abandoned something important about myself just to be there. 

And if a room requires me to continually edit who I am, I have to consider whether it’s a room I really belong in. 

What Does It Mean to Go First? 

I started this podcast because I believe there’s tremendous value in hearing from people who were willing to move before they had everything figured out. 

But this conversation has made me think about another way we can go first. 

Sometimes going first means being the person who is willing to say something honest when everyone else is still deciding whether it’s safe. 

I’ve seen what happens when one person shares something vulnerable in a room. It changes the conversation. Other people start opening up, asking different questions, and sharing things they might otherwise have kept to themselves. 

Someone has to create that opening. 

I think about the people who have done that for me throughout my life, and how much their willingness to be honest has influenced the way I see myself and the world. They probably had no idea what their stories would mean to me. 

And that’s what I keep coming back to. 

I still think about that potential podcast guest, and I hope there comes a time when he feels free to share more of his story. I would genuinely love to hear it, because I suspect there’s a great deal of wisdom in the experiences he feels he needs to protect. 

But more than anything, that conversation has made me pay closer attention to my own choices. 

I don’t want my story to become something that needs to be carefully managed as my career evolves. I don’t want to pull out the vulnerable parts only when they’re useful for a keynote or a podcast conversation. I want those experiences to remain part of who I am and how I show up in the world. 

I know I won’t always get that balance right. There will be moments when I question whether to share something, and there will probably be times when I let fear influence my decision. 

But I want to notice when that happens, because I know how easily those small edits can add up. 

So here’s the question I’ve been sitting with, and one I hope you’ll consider for yourself. 

Where are you already editing yourself as a leader, and whose comfort are you protecting when you do? 

Maybe there’s a part of your story you’ve convinced yourself isn’t appropriate to share. Maybe there’s something you’ve learned through a difficult experience that could change how someone else sees their own situation. 

You get to decide what you share, when you share it, and who gets to hear it. I hope that decision always belongs to you. 

Because there may be someone out there who needs to hear the part of your story you’ve been leaving out. 

And I don’t want either of us to miss that connection simply because we were trying to make everyone else comfortable. 

Want to go deeper into this conversation?
I explored this idea in a recent solo episode of Go First, “The Cost of Editing Yourself.” Listen to the full episode here or wherever you listen to podcasts.

Home » The Cost of Editing Yourself
Privacy Preferences
When you visit our website, it may store information through your browser from specific services, usually in form of cookies. Here you can change your privacy preferences. Please note that blocking some types of cookies may impact your experience on our website and the services we offer.